Thursday, October 26, 2006

Political Correctness???

Wisla Krakow's Nikola Mijailovic was just handed a 5 game ban for allegedly directing racial slurs at Blackburn's Benni McCarthy. I have no doubts that racism occurs in the game. In fact it's one area that frustrates me with europe. They seem 30 years behind the US in addressing the issue both in the game and in society as a whole. My concern is over exactly how it's addressed in the game. In many ways the issue is similar to that over hate crime laws in the US. I've never been a fan of them myself. If you murder someone because they're hispanic instead od murdering them because they slept with your wife or over a drug deal gone bad, I don't see either as being worse than the other. They all show a clear disrespect for human life. The same situation applies to cleaning up things in the game. Is it any worse for a player to commit ungentlemanly conduct if they're trying to get under the other guys skin by telling him his sister's a whore than it is to tell him he's a monkey? And even if you decide that calling a black player a monkey is worse, where do you draw the lines? If you tell a Turkish player that his dad was a Kurdish terrorist is that a plain insult or is that racist? What if a Brasilian player with clear African heritage calls a player from the Ivory Coast a monkey? What if a referee at a game overhears a Somali player telling an African-American player that his mom was a crack whore? Is that a racial insult when it's one black insulting another? And if it is, will the punishment be just as bad as if it a white saying that to a black? Or what an English player tells a Russian player that his dad is a worthless drunk and should lay off the vodka? Is that going to be punished too? My concern is that as they try to clean up the game, 2 things will happen. The first is that the authorities will not anticipate these issues and try to start dialogue on them until they've occured. This will result in inconsistant punishments both in terms of what constitutes racial abuse and the punishments that are handed out My other concern is that it will take decades before the full scope of racism is addressed. That is for too long the definition will be oversimplistic and PC-driven. It will not take into account racist taunts directed at players because their Corsican or Russian or some other form of "white". And it won't take into account the various racial taunts from one "black" player to another "black". It is nice to see UEFA slowly dipping their toe into the water and starting to get involved. But they should've been doing a lot more about this a decade or two ago. And now that they're finally doing something about it, they don't seem to be considering all the aspects of the issue. I

1 comment:

Neilissimo said...

allen,

although I can see your point, a white guy telling a black guy is a 'monkey' is clearly racist and reinforces deluded notions of a racial hierarchy. this must be punished. i can remember in english football stadiums when black players had bananas thrown at them every gAme. only by punishment and education can this be seen to be improved, now in england, it is rare to hear racial abuse at football matches.

of course where do it stop? for example, there is a culture in the u.k to describe something 'irish' as being backwards or inferior, which is in itself, reinforcing a notion of some kind of racial hierachy within the white race, so to say.. of course, any such notion of a hierarchy is insane, but that what it is saying. same for black/black or asian/asian. i described our left-back as a 'welsh fucker' on saturday whilst at the game. heat of the moment and i regret saying it, but 99% of welsh people have not been beaten up, denied a job or made to feel like a second class citizen. black people in europe, and to a larger extent in the usa have. and therein lies the key.

i agree, its a difficult subject and its difficult to draw the line. i personally find 'national' things to be less offensive than 'racial' insults. it seems everytime that a 'western' european club or country plays in 'eastern' europe the racism applied is magnified.